o'brien's test vs empty can test

House Authors

3 min read

·

10-12-2024

43

0

Share

O'Brien's Test vs. Empty Can Test: Choosing the Right Shoulder Instability Assessment

Shoulder instability, the feeling that your shoulder is going to "pop out," is a common complaint affecting athletes and non-athletes alike. Accurate diagnosis is crucial for effective treatment. Two commonly used tests to assess anterior shoulder instability are the O'Brien's test and the Empty Can test. While both aim to identify labral tears and other sources of instability, they differ in their methodology and what they specifically assess. Understanding the nuances of each test is vital for healthcare professionals and individuals seeking a diagnosis.

Understanding Shoulder Instability

Before diving into the tests, let's briefly understand the underlying issue. Anterior shoulder instability occurs when the humeral head (the ball of the shoulder joint) partially or completely dislocates from the glenoid fossa (the socket). This can be caused by various factors, including:

• Labral tears: The labrum is a ring of cartilage that deepens the glenoid fossa, providing stability. Tears in this structure are a common cause of instability.
• Rotator cuff tears: Weakness or injury to the rotator cuff muscles can compromise shoulder stability.
• Ligamentous laxity: Excessive looseness in the shoulder ligaments can predispose individuals to instability.
• Previous dislocations: A history of shoulder dislocations increases the risk of future instability.

The O'Brien's Test: A Comprehensive Assessment

The O'Brien's test is a provocative test designed to assess the integrity of the superior glenoid labrum and the anterior glenohumeral ligaments. It's often preferred for its sensitivity in identifying labral tears and SLAP (Superior Labrum Anterior to Posterior) lesions.

How to Perform the O'Brien's Test:

1. Starting Position: The patient stands with their arm abducted to 90 degrees, horizontally adducted to 10 degrees, and fully internally rotated.
2. Stage 1: The examiner applies downward pressure to the patient's arm. The patient is asked about any pain or clicking.
3. Stage 2: The patient's forearm is then supinated (palm facing upwards), maintaining the same arm position. Downward pressure is again applied, and the patient's pain is reassessed.

Interpretation: A positive O'Brien's test is indicated by pain or a clicking sensation in the internally rotated position (Stage 1) that is relieved when the forearm is supinated (Stage 2). This suggests a potential labral lesion. However, pain in both positions is considered non-specific.

The Empty Can Test: Focusing on Rotator Cuff Strength

The Empty Can test, also known as the Jobe's test, primarily assesses the strength and integrity of the supraspinatus muscle, a key rotator cuff muscle essential for shoulder abduction and stability. While it can indirectly indicate shoulder instability, it’s not as directly focused on labral issues as the O'Brien’s test.

How to Perform the Empty Can Test:

1. Starting Position: The patient stands with arms abducted to 90 degrees, elbows extended, and thumbs pointing downwards ("empty can" position).
2. Test: The examiner applies downward pressure to the patient's arms. The patient resists this pressure.

Interpretation: Weakness or pain during the Empty Can test suggests potential supraspinatus pathology. While a weak supraspinatus can contribute to shoulder instability, the test doesn't directly assess labral integrity.

Comparing the Two Tests

Conclusion: Choosing the Right Test

Both the O'Brien's test and the Empty Can test are valuable tools in evaluating shoulder instability. However, they assess different aspects of the shoulder complex. The O'Brien's test is more sensitive for identifying labral pathology, while the Empty Can test focuses on supraspinatus function. A comprehensive shoulder examination typically involves both tests, along with other clinical assessments and imaging studies, to arrive at an accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment plan. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional for proper evaluation and management of shoulder pain and instability.